Recently, the 4K restorations of Aliens and True Lies have sparked a variety of responses from fans globally, with much of the feedback centering around the perceived loss of the films' original gritty textures. This has echoes of criticism received when Terminator 2 was released in 4K several years ago, which experienced similar backlash.
In light of these remarks, James Cameron has voiced his frustration in a discussion with The Hollywood Reporter, expressing his views candidly. He remarked that some reviewers ought to broaden their perspectives and engage more with the world beyond their current confines.
He elaborated on the meticulous work that goes into these transfers, asserting the expertise of his production team. Cameron emphasized his active involvement, stating that he dedicates himself to overseeing all aspects of color and density in every frame. He highlighted the professionalism of the individual responsible for the final transfer, who has been a long-standing collaborator in his projects. This level of care and attention mirrors the approach taken for all the Avatar films as well.
The tipping point for Cameron seemed to be a critical analysis shared on X from HD Report, comparing the grain quality between the blu-ray edition and the new 4K release. Where do you find yourself in this discourse? Do you resonate with Cameron's stance?